ObsessiveMathsFreak wrote:
There's not much to suggest that the SoLs leave at all. In fact, going by Lilith's behaviour, it seems as though they remain forever on their new world.
Well, there may be an alternative reason for that... Please excuse the vagueness of that statement but I'm still formulating a rather large amount of new ideas in my head.
Eva Yojimbo wrote:
This doesn't seem correct. ADOs are said to have the fruit of Life, LDO the fruit of knowladge. It does not seem likely that the SoLs had the others fruit typre if you will. Truely Adam and Lilith are indeed apple and orange. With this in mind, it seems only a large source of energy, the S^2 organ, is needed for the massive "Genesis Device" AATF. But even this is suspect as Lilith may not have an S^2 organ.
The reason I said this is that the Fruit Combination (FC for short) seems crucial in 3I. IMO, it seems to be crucial in 2I too.
Right now I'm assuming that Lilith intrinsically has the FoK and Adam intrinsically has the FoL:
Adam lay dormant in Antarctica for God knows how long. Why? The Lance was in vim, yes, and we don't yet know why. But going on the quote in 21' it would seem to me that the Lance was already inside Adam at the time of vis awakening ("Pull the Lance back!").
So was it really the Lance keeping vim from waking up? What woke Adam up was, IMO, the CE. The fusion of a human soul with the FoL into a being with the FoK. Now all of a sudden you have a being with both Fruits that's able to create life (the angels), format the planet (2I), and everything.
It probably would've worked too had it not been for the Lance that was already stuck inside vim. IMO, it's the Lance that significantly cut the process short. I'm not entirely sure how, but I'm working on it.
Flash forward to 3I. We end up with not one, but two beings in Lilith and Sho with the FC. Not only that, but if only one fruit was needed to create life, I don't think all the talk regarding the importance of having both throughout the series would've happened.
This theory is still in its developmental stages though. I'm definitely going to have to work out some kinks though. Call it a working hypothesis at the moment.
ObsessiveMathsFreak wrote:
Perhaps it is the SoL itself that made this choice, not its offspring. For example, perhaps Yui makes this choice upon her ascention. Or perhaps Misato is literally referring to the appearance of the Angels, given that both Adam and Lilith are roughly human shaped, but the Angels in the main are not.
I really don't know. Once again, another working hypothesis. But I will say that I don't think Yui played as much of a roll in 3I as some think (once again, sorry for the vagueness.)
ObsessiveMathsFreak wrote:
This would make some sense for ADOs, and would explain Adam's state, however there's no indication that Lilith required such a drastic event at all. Indeed, LDO based life seems to take a much slower, evolution based approach to the creation of life, via the enviornment provided by LCL.
Yeah, that's the one kink in the theory. The entire problem with this is the idea that anything we can invision Lilith doing to create LDO in the beginning doesn't seem to fit when we consider what happened during the creation of ADO during 2I and LDO again during 3I.
ObsessiveMathsFreak wrote:
The process of events you describe cannot be said to have certainly occurred in either First or Second Impact. Lilith was certainly not wiped out, and it's not clear that Adam even used the Lance during second Impact. The events you describe occur during, Thrid Impact with created something totally new, i.e. a new SoL.
When I say "wiped out" I didn't mean in a "gone forever" sense. Think of it like "wiped out" in the how Adam was wiped out sense. I was thinking of it more in that perhaps after creating a new lifeform the uber-being is then reduced to something similar to Adam, and has to take time to regenerate. You bring up Lilith, but in all reality, we don't know what happened to Lilith after she created Lilim.
You bring up an interesting point about 3I creating a new SoL in Yui. "How" though is the question. She already had the FC - so was it her contact with the Lance that turned her into a newly formed SoL?
ObsessiveMathsFreak wrote:I don't believe that the Lance is involved in regular "one fruit" impacts. In fact, it's not clear that it is even required for complementation. However there's a good chance that it is required for new SoL creation.
The Lance is definitely a part of Instrumentality. It was certainly apart of Seele's O3I plans and even in A3I it plays a role in the form of the Eva series. Notice how when they impale themselves how the souls on Earth start to head towards the Black Moon? Now what exactly that means, I don't know.
I wonder if the Lance's role in a SoL creation is to imbue the being's Guf with souls. Remember my referring to the Lance and ToL being connected: I wonder if the Lance "penetrating" Sho/Yui is indication that it's "injecting" her with souls the same way Adam and Lilith have access to souls.
ObsessiveMathsFreak wrote:
It seems unlikely that if the Black Moon itself with Lilith inside could survive the impact, that the Lance presumably within would also be destroyed. More likely is the idea that Lilith never had a Lance at all, it's method of "Seeding" planets being a much slower and more placid affair, not requiring ominous control/security devices etc.
I hate bringing up outside sources (CI), but that seems to be all we have to go on that subject. I think it states something like Lilith's lance was either lost or "possibly" broken with the Black Moon's crash into Earth.
This still doesn't make sense to me, because the Lance, especially in EoE, seems like a sentient thing. For it to become "lost" is weird. For it to be broken though is even more harder to believe though.
ObsessiveMathsFreak wrote:Perhaps Adam had not yet begun the process of creating the Angels at all until it was awoken by the Katsuragi expedition? Perhaos it was still dormant for gathering energy for some reason, but would inevitably waken at some point, which neccessitated SEELEs premature initiation of Second Impact?
As to the Angel's, my opinion is that they were in fact created during Second Impact, and not before, but that is a matter for another thread.
I think a better question is why the hell was the Lance found stuck in Adam in the first place? This makes absolutely NO sense to me. Surely all Seeds don't come impaled on their own Lance like that...