Reichu wrote:Where's this "exclusion from Tangification" stuff come from?
I pointed out earlier that his top half gets bitten off and spirited away, and the potential significance thereof.
From Gendou's own mouth. His talk of his "retribution/punishment" implies he is paying some kind of price here, and temporary pain is unlikely currency. If he is in fact going to join Yui forever, then as that is what he probably always wanted, the line does not fit. Such a fate would be a reward, not a punishment. If his fate is simple complementation, the absense of tangification also does not fit.
This is his "retribution". For what? Abandoning Yui's son? She's lost the moral high groud herself in this regard, and moreover was even understanding of the situation. His many and terrible deeds? If so, Chairman Keel and Co have escaped relatively lightly for theirs. No. There's only one person with enough enmity towards Gendou to both take him away from his wife and exclude him from instrumentality, who has both the means and oppertunity to do so. And that's Shinji
Reichu wrote:And, quite predictably, the "DU-01/Shinji" stuff really doesn't cut it for me.
Could you read over it once more. You're the person I had most in mind as I was writing it.
Reichu wrote:I find that the visual parallelism (Shinji/EVA-01 in #25 and Gendo/EVA-01 in #26'), Yui's visual evolution, and whatever else I mentioned earlier isolates Yui as the culprit in a perfectly satisfactory manner.
Just on the #25 imagery, something you mentioned before
Reichu wrote:...where Shinji encounters this dark, looming, stylized Eva against a red backdrop, the visual manifestation of what "EVA-01" means to him at this point.
I think that this is correct. the images we see in #25 are a visual manifestation of what Unit-01 means
to Shinji. He views it as a monsterous shadow on a red background. It's unlikely that Yui chose to present herself to him in this form. In other words, if Shinji were to manifest himself as Unit-01, this is how he would "imagine himself"(in his own heart).
On the #25 imagery. I really think is is Shinji's personal view of Eva, and not Yui's doing. Going by concurrency of EoTV and EoE, instrumentality probably hasn't begun yet. We have yet to progress through Misato at the lake, Shinji's suicide attempt, Asuka in Unit-02 and Rei and Gendou's meeting. This is probably either Shinji reflecting on his relationship with the Evangelion and his mother, or some sort of communication with the Eva while still inside it shortly following the death of Kaworu. In either case, this is how
Shinji sees the Eva, which is another clue as to the unusually strong appearance of DU-01.
Reichu wrote:IMHO, you're getting too hung up on the matter of Yui's motivations (why she would partially devour her husband, or whatever). For me, this is really a non-issue.
Isn't that the whole point? If we are to understand this scene at all, we need to know why this is happenning. A motivationless Yui just doing things on a whim doesn't really sound convincing. I think even Gendou deserves a little more showmanship.
I think the problem here is the automatic assumption that Unit-01==Yui, and as such when we see Unit-01 in any form, even this substantially different DU-01, we automatically take it to represent Yui. I think this view is mistaken. While it is true that in the great scheme of things, Yui was in Unit-01 all along, this does not automatically make the two inextricably linked within the show, and especially not within its more psychoanalytic imagery.
Indeed, we have one strong instance of Unit-01
not representing Yui. The episode #20 cut of Shinji blending to become Unit-01 as he attacks Gendou. Here very clearly, Unit-01 is the form that Shinji adopts for himself in his own mind. It's the mantle he dons to show his anger and rage. We are certainly not seeing Yui by proxy here. Unit-01 represents Shinji.
Also along this line of thought, consider the strong emphasis EoTV places on the pilots self image. Specifically how their status as pilots has become their raison d'etre. We have Asuka's breakdown as a direct result of her failure to pilot the Eva, and Shinji's regarding his very purpose in life as being the pilot of Unit-01.
Eps #26 wrote:Shinji (OFF):Because right now, the Eva is all I have.
Rei (OFF):Because otherwise, you can't maintain your identity.
Misato (OFF):It's true, Eva Unit 01 is a part of who you are.
RITSUKO (OFF):But if you keep clinging to the Eva, the Eva itself will become you.
Kaji (OFF):The Eva itself will become all you are.
Misato: The real you will cease to exist.
EoTV examines the consumption of Shinji's own identity by the Evangelion. He is in danger of doing what we have done with Yui. Namely, inextricably linking himself with Unit-01. We have his firends warning him that because he basis his sense of self on it, that he is in danger of becoming the Evangelion. It's appropriate then that we would see Shinji represented by what he has slowly become in his own mind since he has been summonned by Gendou to Tokyo-3.
If we saw some great shadowy image, or the Eva we saw was not wearing Unit-01's armour, there would be no reason to associate Yui in any way with the apparition. The only reason we have even considered her as the culprit is because we have unjustifably equated the two seperate
concepts of Yui and Unit-01. The two are seperate ideas, as is proven by the episode #20 scene and Shinji identification of himself with Unit-01. He 's identifying himself with the Eva, as a concept distinct from his mother.
We have been over the existance of distinction between Yui and Unit-01 before, and I think this is the biggest problem in the Yui-centric interpretation of this scene.