Opteron-O3 wrote:I found it interesting that she chose Hikari. Couldn't you say she sees in Hikari a Mother figure? I mean she is the class rep, trustworthy, responsible, etc.. But as I was saying about the mother figure. Asuka obviously trusts her enough to break down on Hikari, and gets sympathy in return. Something Asuka hasn't received (could she be longing for sympathy?) because of how her mother treated her and how everyone else treated her.
So yeah. Is Asuka's relationship with Hikari (in part) based on her unconsciously seeking out a nurturing female figure that she never had?
I can't say that this is really visible in their interactions at all. We never see Hikari apply her authoritative side to Asuka, for instance. If this suggestion was intended, it would have been the simplest thing to have her gently berate Asuka for something, then have Asuka pout and comply - or something like that, you get the idea. Even in the scene of Asuka doing what passes for opening up to her and crying in episode 23, Hikari doesn't really come off as maternal to me, just impotently compassionate.
But taking what we know about Hikari into account, the situation does seem a bit conspicuous. She is, after all, a very minor character. Even the subtle cues to her personality (like her doing the cooking in her family) paint a pretty broad picture. The question is, does that mean her established traits don't matter that much, in which case her being a "mother type" is entirely coincidental to her relationship with Asuka?
Look at it this way: the (quite reasonable) idea that Asuka gravitated toward Hikari because of her elevated social position as a class representative, suggested in the topic I linked to, isn't exactly laid out anywhere in the text either. It's just one of those things that fits. The mother-thing fits too, I'd say.
On the other hand, letting someone serve as a parental substitute in any capacity, with the implicit supplication that entails, could be seen as being at odds with Asuka's drive to be as adult-like as possible. But perhaps that conceit of Hikari being a friend and an equal is exactly what puts her into a position that two actual adults, Misato and Asuka's stepmother, wouldn't be privy to.
Thoughts?