1: What we know about demon & fire maidens legend on the basic level of the storyFirst of course the obvious:
A long time ago, long before the world turned out this way a winged demon lived at the bottom of this town's valley.
The demon spit fire, shook the earth, and caused the people suffering.
Finally, it carried off the Maidens that lived in the fortress, and held them in an underground labyrinth.
But the Maidens lost no heart.
Calling on each other with golden horns, granted to them by an angel, they escaped the labyrinth.
With the aid of a giant spider, they defeated the demon and took its head.
When they did, an intense fire sprung from its head.
If left alone, the town above would burn to the ground.
To keep the springing fire from the town, the Maidens, each in turn, held the head of the demon.
Every day the townspeople cast water upon the flaming head and upon the Maidens.
After one year, the fire had gone.
Since then, to console the spirits of the Maidens who saved the town, they have celebrated the Water-Casting Festival. Well, obviously there is this giant skeleton in the bottom of the river from the ep 1 and the spider is Tank-kun (they even show Tank-kun when they talk about spider)... And it looks like we got "fairly definitive" (read: we still don't know wtf was/is going on but at least we know there indeed was some sort of "demon" instead of whole story being some wonky metaphor for nuclear warfare) answer to this question in ep 7. There was war against "them" that was end of the world as we know it.
The "zombie soldier" from Ep 7 had scribbled this to wall in Japanese (obviously Filicia couldn't read it) before dying:
To Ryoko and Kazuma:
Sorry, but your daddy lost.
I couldn't protect you guys.
It really breaks my heart to
not be able to be be with you guys
in my final moments.
If there is a God in this world
I pray that you guys meet
a peaceful end. Anyway
immeaditly after this we see reflection (and "flap" sound) of giant wing in windows of apartment building. Followed by gigantic red lazor beam that blows shit up in ENORMOUS explosion.
"The demon spit fire, shook the earth, and caused the people suffering" indeed.
Obviously humanity was fucked in war against "them". It looks like they managed to beat them in the end however, albeit not before dealing enough damage to whole planet to kill all sea life and leading world to inevitable, slow death (that is assuming all the talk about world dying out is true but so far there's been no reason to doubt that).
What is far less obvious is that if "Fire Maidens" were girls who lived when "Old World" ended and were responsible for defeating the demon(s). Or whether there was demon left after the war, buried in the ground like Balrog or God Warrior and who woke up and they saved the post-End world from it. In either case this happened long, long ago.''
Then again, ep 11 seems to do it best in other to confuse matters further: according to romans "Demon" was instead Angel of Apocalypse that brought judgement to the world. Whether this is yet another play/expression of show's themes on how a lot of things depend on how we look at them (Kanata vs Rio regarding nature of being lost in ep 10, for example) and we won't get answer ever whether "bird" is demon or angel or whether the story we've been told so far is utterly wrong and "bird" was a good guy in the end I cannot say. In either case it's smart and awesome move from Yoshino's part, starting to question most basic presumptions about the setting just before the big showdown.
Story of "maidens" is apparently different too in Roma. Yumina expresses surprisement when hearing roman version but we don't get to hear it due to Noel freaking out and episode ending. Damnit
Apparently the five girl unit in Seize is purposeful decision: whether this is just another tradition honouring Fire Maidens who supposedly saved the world or whether there's something more sinister behind the "Fortress Maidens" (sacrifice in case of demon re-emerging?) is not known.
As for Tank-kun (if you wonder how it falls in this whole picture) "his"
name Takemikaduchi is crucial clue.
God Izanagi kills other god/
demon Kagutsuchi out of grief. Takemikaduchi is born from blood on Izanagi's sword. So basically Kagutsuchi is
beheaded demon. This doesn't remind us of anything, of course... Most fitting name for possible killer of a revived demon, this Takemikaduchi
(Yoshino's hardon for shinto mythology is quite funny)
These are all the
facts we have currently avalaible on Bird, plot speculah follows later but for now I want to get to the meat of this.
2: Fire Maidens, Rio and Ilya - symbolic level When I first saw episode 1 I immeaditly noticed uncanny similarity in appereances of Rio and "Statue de La Servante du Feu". Filicia even pointed this one out in her usual manner, after conning Rio into playing the part of Fire Maiden in this year's festival: "Looks like I was right in leaving it to her".
At this point of course I could not be sure whether there was going to be any sort of plot or not or whether the legend would play any crucial part in the story (however the mysterious skeleton made me suspect it wouldn't be simple SoL...and I was right) but while watching the scene I thought that if this was going to have plot it would in some way end up mimicking the legend with our girls as the new "Fire Maidens".
Since the whole sequence was so Riocentric - she was the one who played parts of the rite, even collapsed once as if she had been killed - I figured that if Yoshino was going to build parallels between past and present they'd focus most heavily on Rio. Add to her "dying" in the play that she was the mentor figure the likelihood of Rio leaving the group or dying jumped even higher - in some way she was going to die/sacrifice herself by her duty.
Rio left in ep 10, for her destiny - episode that not by chance featured similar sequence.
One thing that interested me in the festivities was the eastern look of the ceremonial clothes - despite oriental elements in SnW even the "mikonun" dresses in western way. And then we end up having Orthodox Roman Empire with its occasionally arabic feel...
But more than that:
...why is she caged? This was what intrigued me most. Now in retrospect - knowing Rio's heritage and past - it seems obvious. Ep 10 also makes it clear the Maiden statue represented Ilya just as much it represents Rio - indeed it could be argued that Maiden is now associated most with Rio because Ilya is no more here. She inherited her unpleasant - to say the least - duty.
Ilya was going to become third wife of the Roman emperor in order to ensure peace between the countries. It looks like the Roman Empire - propably "revived" Holy Roman Empire instead of the original italian one, albeit it seems to have enough eastern influences in it to be actually based on Byzantine too - is pretty much the local superpower. At least they have upper hand in peace negotiations, meaning they have more power. Clues are following
a) the name alone. "Orthodox Roman Empire" creates automatic associations with Rome, the undisputed superpower of its era. This alone isn't very strong but
b) romans have american weaponry & vehicles circa 1943. The catch here is the obvious comparison one is going to make: Rome vs Helvetia = USA vs Germany. We know how huge U.S's material superiority was in WWII.
c) The warfare in ep 7 was in Vingt area which is pretty much the very opposite side of Helvetia from where Seize is located. Yet in ep 11 Rome launches attack from entirely another side. This implies Rome is - at least geographically even if manpower was lacking, there doesn't seem to be much people left in the world anyway - much larger country than Helvetia.
d) most important clue however is without doubt the last one. Phone conversation in ep 8 between Rio and his father, Archduke Arkadia:
"Save" Helvetia? It's obvious peace talks are not going well and it looks like her father now needs his illegitimate daughter in order to secure safety of his country. Now if Rome and Helvetia had about equal military power it would mean war would begin again which of course would be terrible but it really wouldn't mean end of Helvetia would it? The tone in here seems to mean that Helvatia fought long and hard enough to get Rome to negotiations table, but they're spent force. Or at least they're in some way underdog in case war would erupt. Maybe this was the reason why Hopkins used Noel to restore terrifying techniques of the old age in order to win in Vingt?
In any case it's time and time again brought up that if Ilya was alive things would be different:
Ilya was going to marry emperor of the holy city of Rome (lol asshole kingpope, is this Dragonlance all over again?) and become his 3rd wife - an obvious political marriage in order to help relationships and secure peace. Essentially she'd been hostage. Ilya - ever the amazing fucking grace - was going to selflessly do this for her people's sake but then she just had to go and drown two years ago.
Afterwards war erupted and ended only 6 months before ep 1.
Her fate to which she was bound was to be sacrificed for Helvetia's sake. This Maiden/Ilya connection is made clear in ep 10 still montage. It used the same music (instrumental music) as allusion to the festival in episode 1 and they're pretty much sister scenes anyway (in ep 1 Kanata gets lost during this scene, in ep 10 they talk about "being lost" at the end). They both even started with very same shots:
During their walk Rio starts to talk about her past and Ilya:
"I grew up in a small village near the capital, with pretty lakes and forests. I lived there with my mom. It was boring. Nothing ever happened.
My one comfort was my sister, who loved me very much. She was only my half-sister, but she would come and play with me sometimes. I always looked up to her. She was beautiful and kind. And she accepted her fate with pride. I learned the trumpet from her. But she was too kind... And that became her undoing." WHAT she looks at during these latter words is important enough to warrant bigger pics because I want to establish this point clearly:
Ilya = Maiden unity is now established alongside earlier (and more obviously established) Rio/Maiden unity as strongly as possible without literally spelling it out.
In any case Rio has now inherited Ilya's position as saviour of Helvetia. She's not too happy with this though and runs away from his estranged father. But she can't get outside the cage no matter how far she goes. Even in Seize her memories, the bell and of course the mail keeps her tightly binded to her past and situation.
(gorgeous art is gorgeous)
It's not known yet what Rio exactly has to do, albeit marriage replacement would be fairly safe bet. But I'm not absolutely sure about this, unlike 95% of viewers seem to be.
Since Orthodox Roman Empire seems to have slight eastern influence Rio's festival clothing can be seen as hint about nature of her duty. This however is extremely sketchy.
This part of the play can be interprepted in couple of different ways too and we have no way of knowing what's the correct one before finale is over. The dying maiden may symbolize Ilya's demise, Rio's "demise"/acceptance of her faith/leaving 1121st, death of one of our girls (most propably Noel, it's extremely ambiguous if Aisha or Noel was shot in end of ep 11) or simply point where heroines are beaten (after all Rio represents all maidens in that play) before rising again and defeating the enemy ("But the maidens lost no heart.").
******************
Summary: there is more than one level of meaning to the Legend of the Fire Maidens: on literal level it is mythical retelling of real historical events that are still largerly hazy, but more than that it is used to symbolize and foreshadow character arcs, events etc. of the coming show. The festival play manages to symbolically "condense" Rio's life and situation during first 10 eps of show to single scene. That's awesome.
What we're watching in SnW is new version of the that same old play, this time playing out in the "real world" - we of course don't yet know how it will end (if it goes the way of the original myth our main cast is good as dead, but I doubt that'll happen) or all the details. But according to director the myth is going to play big role in finale - in one way or another.
Why I brought this all up? For sake of finale speculah!
We must recognize that "modern replay of the ancient story" does not need to happen on LITERAL level (albeit that's entirely possible) but it can happen on purely symbolical level too - they will not literally fight against "demon" in final episode but against "symbolic" demon.
In fact it may end with both levels happening...one never knows. Especially if there'll be second season this'll become damn likely.