Postby JimmyWolk » Thu Jul 16, 2009 7:58 am
Tunniel - I guess it worked for what it was. Still, "new Angel/EVA" was pretty much just for marketing, it seems.
Clockiel - Disappointing, definitely more so than Tunniel. Aside from also just being a plot device to introduce a new chara, it didn't even do a good job on that. Clean and efficient fighting is one thing, but why not at least show some reactions of the pilot? Sure, they didn't want to introduce Asuka before her dramatic pose, but they didn't really do so with Mari either until her fight ended - though even there they had to rely on the visor for that. Is it that hard just to show the lower half of the face, a flash of a superior grin, etc?
Sahaquiel - very disappointing to me on several levels. 1) The music - the new "catch" song is more dramatic, but it doesn't convey the haste (which is far more important in that scene) at all. 2) The speedramps - NERV seems to have pretty much everything prepared in advance. 3) The look - might be due to the low quality, but it looked like from an N64 game. "Better" than the original in design maybe, but not in execution. 4) Did it really need a face to play to tug with Shinji?
Bardiel - well, was Bardiel. Didn't affect me quite as bad as I thought it would (not so much because I was spoiled, but I thought it to be much worse for me especially because of the "special" circumstances - in fact I think the overall movie made me care less about it than if I had seen it on its own (I guess I put more on the Shikinami thread for this though). The children's song was also less chilling than I expected - was a bit too "normal" instead of totally "cute and harmless" to properly contrast the fight.
And not enough screaming... *pout*
I think I covered Zeruel already earlier...>_>