mastafishere wrote:Fully agree 100%. Her breakdown in episode 23 moves me to tears. To be fair to Colleen and Erica, they're actually really good, particularly Colleen who doesn't get much of a range of emotion to play but certainly conveys the maturity and intelligence that Ritsuko needs to exude.
Wow, I'm shocked they didn't get Trina Nishimura back as Mari. That's a shame, she really gave it her all (though I wasn't a fan of her potty mouth in HA, which is a translation issue, not her fault)
Yeah, she's the reason Episode 23 hits so hard for me as well. I hope 3+1 gives Ritsuko something to do beyond just be the "science woman" facsimile of NGE Ritsuko.
As for Mari, I do wish they kept every Funimation VA who couldn't return from the ADV set, and Mari is basically the pinnacle of the new people imo so this is kind of unfortunate news for me. But I'm willing to give her her own shot. Mari's basically been hard to properly define for the whole Rebuild series anyways, as she sort of activated different between 2.0 and 3.0 (way more irreverent against danger and more bemused by what was going on than concerned, rather than bloodthirsty berserker like she often was in 2.0). So I'm hoping a cohesive full perspective performance of Mari may be able to ease the fact that it seems to be a different VA this time.
Jayfive wrote:As much as she nails it as Mari I'm sure Trina's not to upset about it, she's got a massive fan following due to being Mikasa in AoT. She'll be fine
Yeah. If I recall correctly one of the reasons people were hyped for her casting as Mari is that I think she's half Japanese (or partially? As Nishimura is a Japanese last name.) so similar kind of to Maaya Sakamoto who's bilingual and speaks English perfectly as Mari. I hope Trina's not worried about it, as you speculate.
hui43210 wrote:So it's kinda what I was expecting, a complete mish mash of VAs that managed to get the big three, and possibly Grant too, back to avoid the previous drama. I've haven't heard of the other actors, so I'm curious what studio is actually dubbing this.
Personally, I really liked the Netflix Shinji and Misato, so it bums me out a bit. But most dub fans will be happy, so who am I to complain. Also, I suspect that the new studio worked with Khara to avoid another Funi 3.0 situation, so that'll be a big plus.
I gotta admit that Netflix Shinji at least sounded very good, although different. Much closer to Megumi Ogata in certain parts, such as Shinji's screams in End of Evangelion. That being said I still think it's a performance of an "equal, but different" quality. However I respect people preferring the Netflix cast, and it's just another reason why re-casting them for that was messy, since it divides the fan base, leading to this situation where the final movie is stuck between appeasing two groups. Ideally, they'd have a version with the Netflix people, but that's obviously not happening because there's no incentive, just as there's no incentive for Netflix to reach out to Spike, Alison, Amanda,Tiffany, etc. to make an alternate Netflix dub. It's just messy, as I said.
Edit: And Netflix Misato sounded very good as well. Really, they all did, just that NF Shinji stood out in EoE to me most. Arguably the two casts are equal in performance, it's just that the NF script is a bit clunkier and nostalgia makes the situation with NF more disappointing as a long time fan.
BernardoCairo wrote:Oh, these other characters are Kaworu (Daman Mills), Kaji (Sean Burgos) and Mari (Deneen Melody). No signs of Asuka, unfortunately.
...
This also happened to "EvangelionBR", initially. It only worked for them after using "Hola Plus" (the same VPN used by the original leaker).
So has EvangelionBR independently confirmed the English leak?