Sailor Star Dust wrote:Was having a discussion on Twitter about Madoka and Rebellion with somebody who just finished Madoka, and thoughts on Rebellion are definitely mixed: Most fans who replied besides me were saying to avoid Rebellion/pretend it doesn't exist.
Personally, I'm interested in seeing where the story goes in Movie 4, and I can properly judge Rebellion based on that. Though Rebellion's definitely dark (and I understand that character differences would piss fans off), I enjoyed it for what it was.
I liked rebellion better overall then the series myself. I still say this would be an awesome way to end the franchise, it was a movie that I found enjoyable and also pissed a lot of other people off, thats a great way to end things!
But hey maybe movie 4 will be even better, I thought this was just milking things when i heard they were continuing madoka past the series but was pleasantly surprised with how good the movie was, so maybe it will happen again.