What, just because I had him squirming in the grasp of reason? .. Or it could be that this University attempts to have everything due just before Thanksgiving "break" (essentially a four-day weekend [compared to the three-day weekends 85% of the student body already have every week...

... I just spent ... *checks the clock* and hour responding to tv33 and Wayne ... only to have IExplorer crash and lose everything as I hit the submit button. http://www.evageeks.org/ANF-Archive/images/../images/-noexpression.gif http://www.evageeks.org/ANF-Archive/images/../images/-sad.gif http://w...

Knives, if Lilith is a unique person, capable of free will and with intrinsic worth as an individual, and Rei = Lilith, then doesn't that take care of the problem? .. Not exactly. Because Lilith is the one who is unique, capable of free will and in possession of intrinsic worth. Rei, on the oth...

True. You could argue a (3.5) such as this. And yet her decision to not help Gendo still only justifies her as a tool of SEELE. But ignoring that (since it's not very strong in and of itself) (3.5) doesn't take into account Rei I and II, who also existed. They showed ...

Simple question for you: Is your main objection to the notion that Rei has the soul of Lileth the fact that this would require Lileth's soul to be in multiple places at once? I did already ask you this, but I dare say it got lost in the overall noise, so I ask you again, now. Thank you for aski...

That was my impression, as well. Well, I did apologize for that one instance. And yet, if you only sense the "unpoliteness" (which if finding the irony in his post constitutes being unpolite) in my post and not in his to which i was responding ... well, it doesn't matter. It&#...

*snip* Similarly, even if you somehow manage to get your arm lodged in a chick's navel, she won't demonstrate a capacity to neatly separate and assimilate your appendage: http://www.evageeks.org/ANF-Archive/images/../images/KEG7KHP7KEKPQVLP3AMEFB0DO-m26_C090_rei,gendo_navel-hand.jpg ...and ...

That said, I'm fine with it, and I'm just going to stay out of this one and let the big brains handle it. I'm not qualified for this debate. Just as I would not want others to feel that they cannot speak up for fear of "causing a ruckus and thereby being subject to banning", I...

So... what the heck are all of those things you and Jinpun are throwing around that look like extracts from my high school algebra classes? This post by Jinpun (which quotes me) clearly defines all the symbols: Link http://www.evageeks.org/ANF-Archive/images/../images/-grin.gif Thanks for a...

Alright, glad we are on the same page at last. I think you and I are the only people who managed to follow that conversation http://www.evageeks.org/ANF-Archive/images/../images/ph34r.gif (I'm not saying others didn't ... but from Reichu's reactions to such discussions, I wouldn'...

OK, I understand what you are trying to say now. I agree with this, but I was never under the impression that anyone was saying that. Wayne was saying something to that degree: Even if you succeed in refuting one or two clues, the evidence is still vastly in favor of Rei=Lilith. (For my money, ...

*snip my own section* Jinpun's clear on what I'm saying. So there's no need for what was I said in this section. ------------------------------------------------- you are losing sight of how you actually present yourself and your views. You are inconsistently unpleasant; there is sometim...

Saying: Quote: Originally Posted by Knives The evidence relating to the jump from [C-r] to [C-r'] is some other premise (or premises contained within) [3r]. So using Shinji's dialogue with Misato as evidence in and of itself as evidence for Rei containing Lilith's soul is fallac...

if you are not prepared to provide details about your theory, I don't think that you should criticise the prevalent one. It's not polite I felt the need to address this one line. All this does is provide incentive for people not to speak up. For instance, let's say Magami, Shin-seiki, M...

But you are missing things between [Conclusion-r and r'].[/b] The argument is not saying that only because Rei has come home to where she belongs, that she holds Lilith's soul. It [Conclusion r] just helps support r'. ]. Ok ... Jinpun's on track with me here. This is good http://www...

I would like to re-enforce that point, Knives: almost without exception your formulation of the other side's arguments have been absurd charactiture's of what we have actually said. It doesn't carry much probative value for you to demolish "straw men" that bear almost no resem...

As I said, you are setting up a straw man here; that is not at all how we make our case. The actual process was more like: 1. We examined all the evidence: the multiple associations of Rei with the moon, "You're like me", "I'm home", "welcome home", the explici...

Shouldn't Rei 1 also had to age artificially according to your theory, since first one was also created in 2005? Well .. if you wanted a precise rate of change for the Reis, I'm sure Tines could present us with the mathematical formula ... I probably could too .. but it's 1AM and I'...

... I've said it before, and I say it again at the end of this post — but it would be helpful if people would wait until the Defense of Rei is clearly laid out, rather than have me answer scattered questions in regards to this issue [which as Wayne points out {and I later address} makes for a po...

Gaizokubanou wrote:Wait, so the most popular theory in AN(Rei=Lilith) claims that Lilith's soul was extracted to be given to Rei???

... I know I'm generally the sarcastic one, but is this sarcasm or did you not realize this was the popular belief?

Originally posted on: 16-Nov-2004, 00:48 GMT