I had felt the point of the debate was for you to attempt to convince us of your theory, us to convice you, and in so doing points of view from both sides would be integrated into more complete understanding of the events and characters in Evangelion. Maybe that's just me. That's what happe...

Again, I take that two cents and purchase a gummibear. EDIT: Well, yeah. But one has to admit, the odds of a sensible debate aren't really stacked evenly. The primary objective at the beginning was to prove me wrong, not entertain a new possibility; and everyone was against me from the get go. A...

Okay... gather, link... memory, replay, coffee or no coffee. Fine.



I now have a very firm grasp on the situation. Thank you all for letting me participate.

Originally posted on: 05-Jun-2005, 08:31 GMT

Shin-seiki wrote:(Reposted from anime-forums)

Mon' frere... Do you remember the very debate that started this whole argument? We already agreed that Rei has pre-gathered souls.

Originally posted on: 04-Jun-2005, 13:06 GMT

Wrong, Biscuit is just some nice guy from the UK, whom can't leave my damn coffee alone. I'm the Evangelion forum troll, and nobody(especially not Biscuit) will ever replace me. Nya I tell you, Nya! I see your nya and raise you a boo-nya! Originally posted on: 31-May-2005, 16:11 GMT

I take that $0.02 and purchace a gummi bear.

Hmm... I don't really know what I meant by that, but it felt like the right thing to say.

Originally posted on: 30-May-2005, 05:00 GMT

I haven't seen the storyboards, but I'll take your word for it. Also, could you point me in the direction a thread about this or something, because I'm totally clueless as to why the silent onlooker is Shinji? Is this in the storyboards as well? For that question I recommend you see the...

I will call that a cop-out (or better yet, an obfuscation). While re-used footage is certainly a big part of the "NGE experience" (we see the same shot of Ritsuko over Maya's shoulder about every other episode), this is a whole 'nother thing. It is patently absurd ...

Soluzar wrote:I'm apparently a well-known troll.

Oh, get off it, Soluzar. That was modded. I only flamed you because you were being obnoxious. If it hurts your feelings so much, I'm sorry alright?

PM me later. We'll dicuss it privately.

Originally posted on: 29-May-2005, 18:02 GMT

OMF wrote:And just who is the silent onlooker who turns away?

The kid at the top of the scaffold? That's Shinji.

Originally posted on: 29-May-2005, 17:54 GMT

Then neither should the potted plant. http://www.evageeks.org/ANF-Archive/images/../images/-tongue.gif Which in a way, would support my argument by indirectly proving that the scene is not a part of the mind meld. http://www.evageeks.org/ANF-Archive/images/../images/naughty.gif Of course that only ...

Then what of the children or their "Mama", or the silent onlooker in the sandbox scene? Are these pre-absorbed souls, or fabricated images? They have at least as much screen time as PenPen. I thought they were dolls and manequinns that represented Misato, Rei and Asuka. The sandbox scene ...

These lines have always been rather cryptic. What is she saying here? Translation glitch? Well, try it. Smack your mom across the face and see how it feels. Okay, I really don't want you to do that. Bad joke. But for a self destructive guy like Shinji, hurting others hurts him a lot. Originally...

Oy-vey! Here we go again... Uh, Vicil, to the extent that your thesis depends on the the idea that Pen^2's presence somehow proves that the Kitchen Scene is a previously unseen incident in the "real world" continuity, I really don't 'get' where you're coming from. Let&#...

I kindly decline your challenge. I've said my peace.

Originally posted on: 29-May-2005, 06:45 GMT

Then go look for it. It's linked a few posts up, and I'm not going to make it easy for you since you obviously ain't giving me respect.

Originally posted on: 29-May-2005, 06:41 GMT

That's also you opinion, and as for your opinion of me, please stop attempting to deconstruct me with your cliche' Jersey pretty-boy slang. There is ENOUGH evidence to support the possibility, and I even surmized the evidence AND discrediting evidence in the very first post I wrote on AN; so...

Why should I even feel the need to prove it's existence when all I'm presenting is a possibility. There's usually little hard evidence for a possibility. It's about where you put your faith. Unless you want me to prove it real so "It can be written." It's not like your ...

Long assed reply Admittedly your opinion of Shinji is more positive than mine. There is almost no difference between our POVs except that *I* think he is capable of more violent outbursts... which only changes where to put the blame for so&so's actions. (IMHO) Hurting others to hurt...

Damn that Asuka, some things I just don't get about her. She must have good feelings for Shinji, yet she hates him so. A lot of that ambiguity is tied into their relationship.

Originally posted on: 28-May-2005, 19:37 GMT